The Drawbacks of Market-Based Approaches to Environmental Protection | CBCGDF Climate Change Working Group

Market-based approaches to environmental protection, while initially promising, often reveal significant drawbacks that undermine their effectiveness. The primary concern is the inherent conflict between ecological sustainability and market-driven objectives, which prioritize profit maximization over environmental integrity.

One of the most common market-based tools, carbon trading, exemplifies these issues. While intended to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, carbon markets can lead to perverse outcomes. For example, the creation of carbon offsets can incentivize the displacement of emissions rather than their reduction, leading to "carbon leakage" where emissions are simply moved to regions with less stringent regulations. This does not address the root cause of environmental degradation but rather shifts the problem elsewhere.

Additionally, market-based approaches can exacerbate social inequalities. Access to environmental goods and services, such as clean air and water, becomes commodified, often pricing out marginalized communities who are already disproportionately affected by environmental hazards. This marketization of nature can lead to a "green gentrification" where natural areas are preserved for the affluent, while low-income neighborhoods continue to suffer from environmental neglect.

While market-based approaches aim to leverage economic incentives for ecological protection, they often fall short due to their focus on profit and the potential for creating new environmental and social injustices. A more holistic and equitable approach is needed to truly safeguard our planet's ecosystems.

 

Translator: Richard

Checked by Sara

Editor: Richard

Contact: v10@cbcgdf.org; +8617319454776


Contribution

Do you know? CBCGDF is a non-profit organization. We rely on crowd-funding and donations. You have the opportunity to help us to advance biodiversity conservation. Donate TODAY to power up the movement to make it a better world for all life.

 

1. Webpage:

https://www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=2EYYJJZ8CGPLE

2. via paypal

Donation（501C3）Paypal： intl@wbag.org

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Bridging Borders for Wildlife: John E. Scanlon AO Recognized with China's Highest Honor - Chinese Government Friendship Award

Image
Congratulations to our dear friend and best teacher, John E. Scanlon AO, for honored the remarkable achievement - The Chinese Government Friendship Award!   On September 27, 2023, the Ministry of Human Resources and Social Security (State Administration of Foreign Experts Affairs) held a prestigious ceremony in Beijing to present the Chinese Government Friendship Award. The Chinese Government Friendship Award is China's highest honor bestowed upon foreign experts who have made outstanding contributions to the country's modernization and reform and opening-up efforts. John E. Scanlon AO, an esteemed ecological conservation and sustainable development expert hailing from Australia (UK), received this distinguished award. His unwavering commitment and significant contributions to global wildlife conservation efforts, along with his deep friendship with people of China, earned him the Chinese Government Friendship Award. John E. Scanlon has dedicated his life to the protection of a
Read more

The 2024 World Water Forum Opens in Indonesia's Bali

Image
The 2024 World Water Forum (10th WWF) under the theme of "Water for Shared Prosperity" officially opened on Indonesia's island of Bali on Monday. This year ’ s theme emphasizes the need to work together to promote efficient and integrated water resources management to common prosperity. The 10th WWF ’ s six subthemes are: Water Security and Prosperity; Water for Humans and Nature; Disaster Risk Reduction and Management; Governance, Cooperation and Hydro-diplomacy; Sustainable Water Finance; and Knowledge and Innovation. This year, the Forum is expected to host 350 sessions, and receive 100,000 participants and visitors, 56 ministers, 12 heads of state, and about 2,000 journalists. The 10th World Water Forum focuses on four topics, namely water conservation, clean water and sanitation, food and energy security, and mitigation of natural disasters. The 10th WWF   is jointly organized by the Government of the Republic of Indonesia and the World Water Council. The Forum is th
Read more

Dr. FANG Jun, Secretary General of CBCGDF One Health Working Committee Leads the Construction of ESG System for the Medical Device Industry

Image
" T he First ESG &   China Medical Device Development Forum" organized by   China Association   for Medical Device Industry , Smart & Mobile Medical Branch of China Association   for Medical Device Industry and Reed Sinopharm Exhibitions was held in Shenzhen   o n October 28, 2023, . The Forum   launched the construction of an ESG system for the medical device industry. At the meeting, Dr. F ANG   Jun, Secretary-General of the One Health Working Committee of China Biodiversity Conservation and Green Development Foundation (CBCGDF), was selected as the chief expert to lead the organization of relevant professional and academic research work on the construction of the ESG system. As the first important event for the construction of the ESG system of the medical device industry held by the "China Medical Device Industry Association ESG Task Force", this forum not only created a good atmosphere for the development of the ESG industry, but also provided a platfor
Read more